Dick Williams was nothing more than a role player for most of his 13 seasons in the professional ranks, including his last two seasons as a member of the Red Sox in 1963 and 1964, but Dick O’Connell, then an assistant general manager with the club, recognized his potential as a coach and assigned him a role as a player-coach with Boston’s AAA farm club, the Seattle Rainiers, after the 1964 season. However, circumstances led to the Red Sox relocating the affiliate to Toronto and manager Edo Vanni refusing to move with the team, so Williams quickly leapfrogged into the role as manager of the new baseball Maple Leafs. Presented with the opportunity to succeed where his playing career had failed, the young 36-year-old manager guided his team to consecutive Governors’ Cups as champions of the International League. Subsequently, with O’Connell now in charge of the parent club, Williams was offered a contract to take over for a team that, unlike the Maple Leafs, had floundered for the past two seasons, not to mention for the past eight years.
Williams immediately grabbed the attention of his club at spring training in 1967, announcing that Carl Yastrzemski was being stripped of his title as captain and ordering the immortal Ted Williams, in camp as a roving batting instructor, to pack his bags and go home; in other words, he made it clear from day one that there was only one person in command of the ship and that he was resting the success of his young club entirely on his shoulders. With his no-nonsense attitude, Williams was quick to bench players that he felt were not making the effort that they should, be they rookie or veteran ballplayers, and he was quick to tear players apart privately and in public.
His style was unorthodox for a franchise that had become used to coddling star players, recklessly abusing youngsters, and caring little about the results on the field but, with time, Williams got what he wanted from veterans like Yastrzemski as well as some of the younger players like first baseman George Scott and pitcher Jim Lonborg. He also urged O’Connell to make trades for players that he felt would help the club now, like Jerry Adair and Gary Bell. Soon, his efforts translated to success on the field, as the club stayed around .500 for the first half of the season, then took off and won 51 of its remaining 80 games after the All-Star break. Above all, a team that many had felt was destined for another finish in the American League cellar instead celebrated its first American League pennant in over 30 years at the end of the season.
Having managed under a one-year contract for the 1967, Williams was quickly signed to a new three-year deal after the season; however, the magic of 1967 was short-lived and his clubhouse tactics soon backfired against him. Though the second-year manager guided the team to its second winning record in as many seasons, the team finished 17 games behind the pennant-winning Detroit Tigers, disappointing to those who now expected the team to steadily improve, including a revived fan base. What had worked so well for the team one year had failed them the next as the numbers of nearly every key member of the 1967 club slid. Williams also found that he could only push players so far, especially Yastrzemski, who was a favorite of owner Tom Yawkey. 1969 did not fair much better for him and his club and, under pressure from Yawkey, O’Connell was forced to fire Williams with just a handful of games left in the season.
Williams, however, was far from done with managing in baseball. In 1971, Oakland Athletics owner Charlie Finley hired him to manage his club and the young manager responded by leading his new team to a division title. Over the next two seasons, with players like starting pitchers Catfish Hunter, who won 20-plus games in each season, Vida Blue, and Ken Holtzman along with offensive threat Reggie Jackson, Oakland won consecutive World Series titles, besting the Cincinnati Reds and the New York Mets in 1972 and 1973, respectively. However, due to another falling out with an owner, Williams resigned after three seasons in Oakland. He would then go on to manage in California, Montreal, San Diego, and Seattle before calling it a career after the 1988 season at age 59, winning another pennant with the Padres in 1984 and becoming only the fourth manager at that time to win pennants in both the American and National leagues. In 2006, Williams was elected to the Red Sox Hall of Fame and he has twice been given consideration by the Baseball Hall of Fame’s Veterans Committee but failed to get elected, most recently this past February as he received better than just one-third of the vote.