An East Boston native and a graduate of St. Mary’s High in the nearby suburb of Lynn, Tony Conigliaro got the opportunity to live the dream of New England school boys everywhere when he signed with the Boston Red Sox in September of 1962. With Boston’s intermediate Single-A affiliate in Wellsville, NY the following year, “Tony C,” as he was known later to Boston fans, tore through the Pennsylvania-Ontario-New York League (known today as the New York-Penn League), batting .363 with 24 home runs and 74 RBI in only 83 games. It was only too easy then for newly-crowned Boston manager Johnny Pesky to find a spot for the 19-year-old prodigy on the major league roster the following spring in Arizona. Less than a month later, stepping to the plate at Fenway Park for the first time, he took a pitch from Chicago White Sox pitcher Joe Horlen over the Green Monster and onto Lansdowne Street for his first career major league home run; with that, a legend was born.
By late July of his freshman campaign in the majors, Conigliaro had smashed 20 home runs and driven home 42 runs, but an errant pitch thrown by Cleveland’s Pedro Ramos on 26 July in the second game of a doubleheader sidelined the young outfielder for over a month. He eventually finished with a .290 average, a career high, 24 home runs, and 52 RBI in 111 games played, but the injury had ruined his chances to walk away with American League Rookie of the Year honors, which instead went to Tony Oliva. Over the next two seasons, he would continue to demonstrate remarkable power numbers at the plate, becoming the youngest player ever to win the home run crown in 1965 after collecting 32 long balls and hitting another 28 the following season.
1967 saw Conigliaro jump out to a strong start. Before a two-week stint on the disabled list in late May, he was batting .304 with two home runs and 15 RBI; when he returned, he hit eight home runs and drove home another 26 runs in the month of June while keeping his average close to .300. In July, he hit another nine round-trippers, highlighted by career number 100 in the first game of a doubleheader on 23 July off John O’Donoghue of Detroit to become the youngest player to reach that milestone. As Boston ended a road trip the same day having won ten straight to close within a half-game of first place, fans and the media were caught up in pennant fever and Conigliaro, along with his teammates, were on the verge of greatness.
Unfortunately, his part in the pursuit of a long-overdue championship for the franchise was instantly shattered on 18 August. Settled into the batter’s box in the bottom of the fourth inning at Fenway Park, California Angels pitcher Jack Hamilton threw his first pitch high and inside; Conigliaro never had a chance as the pitch struck his face below his left eye, causing his cheekbone to get crushed and his eye ball to implode. Conigliaro immediately dropped to the ground as coaches and players raced to his aid and the Fenway crowd sat in stunned silence. Conigliaro not only missed the rest of the “Impossible Dream” season but the 1968 campaign as well as he recovered from the devastating injury.
His return in 1969 earned him Comeback Player of the Year honors as he socked 20 home runs and plated 82 runs in 141 games; he followed that season with career-highs of 36 home runs and 116 RBI in 1970. To the surprise of everyone outside the organization, Boston traded the beloved Conigliaro that October to California, but he lasted just 74 games with the Angels in 1971 before he announced his retirement at age 26 due to lingering problems with his eyesight.
Not willing to hang up the cleats for good, Conigliaro made one last attempt to return to the game he loved. With the addition of the designated hitter’s position in 1974, he figured he might be able to make an impact with his bat for the club and told Boston in November of 1974 that his depth perception was back 100%. The following April, on Opening Day against Milwaukee at Fenway, 30-year-old Tony Conigliaro made his triumphant return to the Boston lineup and received four standing ovations, responding to the warmth of the crowd with a single in his first at-bat. However, the good times were short-lived as he appeared in only 21 games, batting just .123 with two home runs, before making his last appearance for the Red Sox on 12 June, grounding out to second in his last at-bat.
Following retirement, Conigliaro moved away to San Francisco and found work as a sportscaster on a local area television station. When a position became available to become a television analyst for the Red Sox, he jumped at the opportunity to return to his roots and flew back to Boston in early January 1982. Unfortunately, as he was being driven back to Logan Airport by his brother Billy to return to California, he suffered a massive heart attack that left him severely incapacitated. Tragically, he died in 1990 in Salem, MA; he was just 45 years of age.