Signed as an amateur free agent by the Red Sox in May of 1962, George Scott made his mark by winning the Eastern League Triple Crown and MVP with Double-A Pittsfield in 1965; his efforts at the plate as well as on the field at first base made it easy for new Red Sox general manager Dick O’Connell to promote the youngster to Boston for the 1966 season. Although just 22 years of age, he made a quick impression in the American League, tearing out of the gate with 11 home runs and a 14-game hitting streak between late April and the middle of May, putting his batting average as high as .355. His fast start earned the man nicknamed Boomer a nod as the starting first baseman in the Mid-Summer Classic of 1966, the first rookie to start an All-Star game since former American League Rookie of the Year and Red Sox first baseman Walt Dropo in 1950. Though he would tail off as the season progressed, hitting just .245 and striking out 152 times, he hit 27 total home runs and collected 90 RBI playing all 162 games that season, enough to earn him third place in the Rookie of the Year vote.
Despite his success in 1966, Scott was met with resistance to begin 1967, not because of the color of his skin, which had for several years made it next-to-impossible for a black ballplayer to make it with Boston, but because new manager Dick Williams was not going to show favoritism to anyone, starting All-Star first basemen included. Only five games into the season and batting .182 despite getting a hit in four of those starts, Scott was benched and given pinch-hitting duties for three straight games as punishment. When asked about his relationship with the second-year player, Williams growled: “Trying to talk to George Scott is like talking to cement.”[1] Though his tactics seemed irrational and demeaning on the surface, it was the rookie skipper’s way to try and motivate his players to reach a level where the club had not been for more than two decades. Back in his starting role after his brief stay in Williams’ doghouse, Scott responded with six hits in his next thirteen at-bats to raise his average up to .270, the start of a 20-game span in which he got at least one hit per game 18 times and raised his average to a more-impressive .311. His season would end with a .303 batting average, good enough for fourth in the American League, 19 home runs, 82 RBI, and AL MVP consideration. Also, despite 19 errors at first for a .987 fielding percentage, Scott won the first of two consecutive Gold Gloves with Boston and eight all-told in his career.
As well as Scott did at the plate in his first two seasons, no one expected him to slump as badly as he did in 1968, dropping his average to .171 in 124 games played, while stroking on three home runs and 25 RBI. The next season, he was moved across the diamond to third base and stayed there for nearly two seasons as he regained his stroke. His average climbed each season (.253 and .296, respectively), while hitting another 32 home runs combined. In 1971, he returned to his regular position at first base and won a third Gold Glove award, appearing in 143 games in that role while making just 11 errors for a .992 fielding percentage. However, despite 24 home runs and 78 RBI, numbers which approached his then-career highs, his average slipped once more to a mediocre .263. With 1967 a near-distant memory in Boston, O’Connell and the front office, feeling pressured to return to the playoffs at any cost, sent Scott, fellow 1967 teammate Jim Lonborg, and four other Red Sox players to Milwaukee shortly after the season ended in a huge ten-player deal.
Scott did no better in his first season with the Brewers but seemed to regain form in 1973, stroking 24 home runs and 107 RBI while establishing a career-high in batting average of .306; two years later, he batted .285 while further establishing career highs with a league-leading 36 home runs and 109 RBI while making his second All-Star team. His defensive skills had not diminished, either; he won Gold Gloves in each of his five years with Milwaukee, which today places him third all-time at that position behind Keith Hernandez (11) and Don Mattingly (9) for career Gold Gloves. He also proved durable, appearing in all but 22 games over that time. In 1977, Scott returned to Boston in a trade along with Bernie Carbo for Cecil Cooper, and enjoyed one more great season with a career-high 103 runs scored, 33 home runs, and 95 runs driven in while batting .269 and slugging .500, earning another appearance on the American League All-Star roster. Unfortunately, his homecoming was short-lived; the next season, he batted only .233 for the Red Sox while slipping to just 12 home runs and 54 RBI in 120 games played.
He would play just one more season before hanging up his cleats for good, finishing his career with a .268 average and 271 home runs; with Boston, he hit 154 home runs, placing him 15th all-time in franchise history. In 2006, along with his former manager from the “Impossible Dream” season, Dick Williams, George Scott was inducted into the Red Sox Hall of Fame.
[1] Stout and Johnson, Red Sox Century: The Definitive History of Baseball’s Most Storied Franchise, Expanded and Updated (Sport in the Global Society)
. Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston, 2005. 544 pp.